Member Access
Member Access
×

Beyond Invasion: Rethinking the Metaphors of Migration

Chelsea Couture holds a PhD from the Department of Translation and Language Sciences at the Universitat Pompeu Fabra. She teaches courses in social movements, gender and communication, intercultural communication, and related subjects in Barcelona. Her research examines metaphor, narrative, political discourse, and feminist approaches to leadership.

Pests that need exterminating, aliens invading, or a wave bringing mass destruction—migrants and migration are rarely conceptualized in neutral ways. Dominant metaphors often depict migrants as a problem or threat that must be controlled, contained, or eliminated. This language was evident in U.S. President Donald Trump’s 2025 inaugural address when he stated, “I Will send troops to the southern border to repel the disastrous invasion of our country” (Trump, 2025). What happens when we change the metaphors through which we understand migration? Metaphors do not serve as mere linguistic expressions. They shape what imaginaries are available by framing one thing in terms of another. They highlight certain aspects of a problema while concealing others, influencing not only how the problem is depicted, but also who is held responsible and what possible solutions become available.

Image 1 (Rosiette-Stock, via Wikimedia Commons. CC0 1.0.). Dominant migration discourse frequently relies on metaphors of invasion, threat, and containment.

Whether it’s preparing for a flood or eliminating an unwanted intruder, these metaphors activate conceptual frames that dehumanize migrants, problematize migration, and propose reactionary, and often violent, solutions. Within the narrative woven by these metaphors, migrants are a dangerous force, nations are threatened, and containment is required. These metaphors can obscure the fact that migration itself is not a modern phenomenon; human populations have moved across territories throughout human history. Yet, how we as a society conceptualize immigration can change how we understand it, relate to it, and what solutions to current migration issues are available. For example, within the frame of dominant metaphors, immigration becomes a threat for which containment, exclusion, or elimination appear to be logical responses, yet migration itself is not necessarily the problem. Current challenges emerge from the conditions that produce migration and from how governments and institutions respond to it. Dominant discourse can obscure this distinction by constructing migrants themselves as the threat.

But what happens when immigration is conceptualized through a different metaphor—one that directs our attention toward the human toll and the interconnected nature migration? In my doctoral research on metaphor, narrative, and political leadership, among the metaphors analyzed on immigration one such alternative in the immigration discourse of the former U.S. Vice President Kamala Harris. In an interview with VICE News (2022), Harris briefly activated the metaphor of immigration as a complex organic structure, offering an alternative way of conceptualizing migration. Here, she uses the language of “roots” to activate an organic conceptual domain in which immigration can be understood in relation to something living, such as a tree or plant. Reading this metaphor through an ecological lens highlights its relational logic. Ecology is concerned not simply with individual organisms but with relationships: between organisms, environments, resources, and the conditions that allow systems to sustain themselves. Through this perspective, the metaphor of roots shifts attention from the migrant as an isolated “problem” toward the interconnected political, economic, social, and familial conditions within which migration occurs. In this interconnected system, people and institutions are mutually related actors. The problem thus shifts from migrants themselves toward the unhealthy or unsustainable conditions surrounding migration. This framing opens space for solutions centered on support, reform, and integration. In this context, migration is understood as a process embedded within relationships among families, communities, institutions, economies, and governments rather than an individual act to be feared. Unlike dominant frames, this reimagining raises the question: what conditions have produced this situation, and what conditions would allow individuals and communities to flourish?

Image 2 (Official White House Photo by Lawrence Jackson. Public domain). Kamala Harris’s reference to the ‘root causes’ of migration activates an alternative organic conceptual frame.

This metaphor does not come without its limitations, the first and foremost being its limited use and dissemination. Even Harris only activated this metaphor briefly while referring to the root causes of migration. Moreover, just because this metaphor offers a new view does not make it inherently equitable. Ecological language itself is not automatically humane, what matters is the relationships and values a metaphor constructs. For example, who decides what counts as healthy? Who gets cultivated—and who gets treated as invasive? And who belongs within that ecosystem? As engaged citizens, we need to continue to ask these questions in order to create alternative imaginaries of immigration that treat migrants first as human beings embedded in families, communities, histories, and social conditions rather than reducing them to threats.

Image 3 (Kuraplan, licensed under CC BY-NC 4.0.). Like roots beneath the surface, the metaphor of immigration as a complex organic system directs attention toward the interconnected conditions within which migration occurs.

Migration is just one piece of the puzzle. Issues related to climate, economy, poverty, gender, war, and social justice all depend, in part, on the metaphors through which problems become intelligible. Critical awareness of discourse should not remain confined to academia; it should become part of how citizens engage with public communication. As citizens we can begin to ask questions that challenge dominant discourse, discourse that positions migrants as invaders, the economy as a machine, and pandemics as wars. We can start by asking: What metaphor am I being asked to accept? Who does it give agency to? Who does it make responsible? What bodies are being harmed within this narrative? What solutions does it propose? What might become possible if we told the story differently? By imagining alternatives, we can begin to recognize that language does not simply reflect the worlds we inhabit, but it is a central player in constructing the worlds we consider possible.

REFRENCES

Couture, C. (2026). Conceptual metaphors and socio-political narratives: Creating alternatives through feminist approaches to political discourse [Doctoral dissertation, Universitat Pompeu Fabra].

Lakoff, G., & Johnson, M. (1980). Metaphors we live by. University of Chicago Press.

Landers, L. (2022, September 16). VP attacks MAGA governors for “playing games” with “real human beings.” VICE News.

Trump, D. J. (2025, January 20). Inaugural address. The American Presidency Project.